Suspended from PERM? The NIW Path for Engineers Working for One Employer (Part 2)

In Part 1, we discussed the Department of Labor's October 8 PERM suspension of eight large technology and IT-services and other recent PERM challenges. We also covered EB-1A and the O-1 visa as alternative solutions.
·
·
November 3, 2026
Documents and laptop on a desk
Make Summary with AI:

In Part 1, we discussed the Department of Labor's October 8 PERM suspension of eight large technology and IT-services and other recent PERM challenges. We also covered EB-1A and the O-1 visa as alternative solutions.

This part covers the option many affected engineers will consider first, the EB-2 National Interest Waiver.

The National Interest Waiver

The NIW lets you petition for yourself, bypassing the PERM. Under Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), you must show three things:

  1. Your proposed endeavor has substantial merit and national importance.
  2. You are well positioned to advance it.
  3. On balance, it would benefit the United States to waive the job offer and labor certification requirements.

Why the NIW is harder when you work for one large employer

In Dhanasar, the AAO said national importance depends on the specific endeavor, not on how important your field is. USCIS's January 2025 Policy Manual update points the same way. Work that mainly benefits one company and its customers is often found to lack national importance, however skilled the person doing it.

An engineer whose petition simply describes their current job will often receive a Request for Evidence on this point: Your work is valuable for your employer, but how does it affect the field or the nation?

How we address it

  • Define  the endeavor, not the job. The proposed endeavor is a forward-looking     description of what you will do in your field. Your employer can be where you do it now, but it should not be the whole story. "Developing machine learning methods for medical imaging" is an endeavor. "Working as a Senior Software Engineer on the ML Team" is a job title.
  • Be specific. The main challenge is finding the right balance between defining the endeavor too narrowly (working for one company and benefitting only this company and its clients), and too broadly (describing your field in general instead of specific things you actually do and how they benefit the nation). This is very case-specific, but the idea is to be as specific as possible without tying the endeavor to only one company.
  • Show impact beyond the company. The strongest evidence shows that people outside your employer use or rely on your work, for example:
       
    • systems that serve critical sectors such as health care, cybersecurity, energy, or government infrastructure
    •  
    • contributions to industry standards
    •  
    • licensed products used across the industry
    •  
    • open-source projects adopted by other organizations
    •  
    • patents cited or used by other companies
    •  
    • publications and conference talks
  •  
  • Connect  the work to stated national priorities, where that is accurate. Federal programs, executive orders, lists of critical and emerging technologies help show national importance. They must be paired with your specific endeavor, not just the field as a whole.
  • Use independent experts. Letters from people who know your work but have never worked with you carry more weight than letters from your coworkers when it comes to proving the national importance of your work. However, letters from your managers or collaborators are critical to show the nature of your endeavor, your past success and prospective benefit of your specific work.
  • Show  the endeavor survives a job change. Show that there is demand for specialists like you in other companies. It strengthens the second prong, and it protects you if you change employers while the case is pending. An NIW belongs to you, not to your employer.

One more argument is worth noting, though it is untested. Under the third prong, Dhanasar considers whether it would be impractical to obtain a labor certification given the nature of the applicant's qualifications or proposed endeavor. If your employer is barred from PERM, the barrier comes from the employer, not from the nature of the work, so we would treat it as a supporting point at most and never as the foundation of a case.

If you are gathering evidence for an NIW, EB-1A, or O-1petition, our two-part series on AI for O-1, EB-1, and NIW Applicants explains how to organize it efficiently.

Where to Start

If you are on an H-1B at one of the affected employers, gather four things before a consultation:

  1. Your H-1B start date and total time used, including any time outside the U.S. that can be recaptured.
  2. The status of any PERM or I-140 your employer has already filed.
  3. Your complete CV, with a list of your largest projects, patents, publications, talks, open-source work, review or judging roles, and press mentions.
  4. Your spouse's status, and whether they rely on an H-4 EAD.

With that information, we will be able to tell you in a consultation whether EB-1A, NIW, O-1, or a combination is realistic, and develop the best strategy.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice. The PERM suspension was announced without a published written notice, and its scope may change. Consult an immigration attorney about your specific situation.

‍

This website is for general information purposes only, and is not intended to serve as a source of legal advice. Neither receipt of information presented on this site nor any email or other electronic communication sent to our firm through this site will create an attorney-client relationship. You should consult with an attorney about your specific situation. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.